Buy the book version
Common Core Math For Parents For Dummies—a handbook for curious parents and others—is out now! Priced at under $10 on Amazon.The Talking Math with Your Kids Store
You can buy tiling turtles, pattern machines and my book Common Core Math For Parents For Dummies, (with more items coming soon) at the Talking Math with Your Kids Store

Recent Posts
Comments
 I <3 Fractions #MTBOS30 (3)  (Mis)Adventures in Mathland on Common numerator fraction division [#algorithmchat]
 Math Teachers at Play #97 Blog Carnival  DeniseGaskins.com on The sequence machine
 Systems of Linear Equations – Thanks #mtbos!  judylarsen on My Oreo manifesto
 Christopher on Questions from middle school teachers: Division of fractions
 Lucy Atkins on Questions from middle school teachers: Division of fractions
What have people read recently?
Subscribe by RSS
Categories
 Assessment (5)
 Connecting teachers (3)
 Courses (8)
 Curriculum (49)
 Diagrams and decorations (12)
 For further learning (1)
 Language (14)
 Launch (3)
 Lessons (20)
 Metaphors (3)
 News (42)
 Opinion (38)
 Presentations (4)
 Problems (math) (49)
 Problems (teaching) (40)
 Questions from middle school students (10)
 Questions from middle school teachers (6)
 Reflection (38)
 Talking math with your kids (76)
 Technology (15)
 The end of word problems (19)
 Truly unfortunate representations of data (8)
 Uncategorized (33)
Tags
4 years old 5 years old 6 years old 7 years old 8 years old addition algebra algorithms borders calculus ccss CGI CMP college algebra common core counting curriculum data decimals developmental mathematics diagrams division division of fractions fractions functions geometry graphs Griffin groceries hexagons inverse iwb khan khan academy language lattice learning listening to students logarithms math math for elementary teachers math methods measurement middle school multiplication nature of mathematics nctm new york times number number language numeration online learning oreos ph place value probability problems professional development questions rate rates ratio ratios sharing standards systems of equations Tabitha TDI Technology twitter units video wcydwt wiggins word problemsStuff I write
Support the work
AWESOME. ^_^
What he said. I’m not sure how evocative it is as a standalone image, but it’s quite clever with just a bit of thought.
Have you ever used this with your students? If so, how did they react?
The vending machine metaphor actually resonates with my College Algebra students pretty well every semester. Several students have come back to me and mentioned using vending machines to think about functions in later courses.
Of course, we deal with the formal definition of function, and with more abstract imagery as well. But I really do think we ignore this sort of informal imagery at our (and our students’) peril. They’ll form images whether we support that process or not.
And I’m agreed that these don’t work as standalone images. You do need to think them through, and discuss them.
Plus they’re fun.
Oh, by the way. I don’t test my students on their ability to use the vending machine metaphor. The standard is about functions. Vending machines are a route to the standard, but are not the standard.
Pingback: Actually, it’s not like that at all… (failed metaphor)  Overthinking my teaching
Christopher, how do you expand on this with the students?
What’s the domain and range of your “identity” function?
Values. Domain is {1,5}. Range is {1,5}. Function is {(1,1), (5,5)}.
Pingback: Sameness in College Algebra  Overthinking my teaching
I love this. I normally usee the example of a toaster. The white bread is the input; the toaster is the FUNction rule; the toast the output. NOW, what type of FUNction is the toast? If I put in rye bread, I still get toast out, just like if I toasted wheat.
Thanks for the ideas and for keeping me thinking how I approach the topic of FUNctions w/ my students.
I love the different vending machines idea.
Oh, one thing I try to do is ask my students what do they see…in hopes of getting to ‘sameness’. Maybe there’s something they see I don’t see.
This is great. Any idea on how we use this metaphor with an onto function?