A Truly Unfortunate Representation of Data accompanied a recent article on British pizza toppings.
So much bad data representation wrapped into a single image. Make sure to read the fine print!
A Truly Unfortunate Representation of Data accompanied a recent article on British pizza toppings.
So much bad data representation wrapped into a single image. Make sure to read the fine print!
A Truly Unfortunate Representation of Data (T.U.R.D.) from Fox News.
Posted without comment.
Thanks to David Radcliffe for passing it along on Twitter.
With thanks to Dan Meyer for finding this particular Truly Unfortunate Representation of Data [TURD]:
It is becoming clear that online colleges are major sources of TURDs.
A few of the TURD-lectable features in this one:
One last point (and it was Dan’s original point in posting it in the first place): Garbage in/garbage out in terms of information and purpose. You could fix the critiques above and the graphic still stinks; was any student ever convinced to keep on keepin’ on in math class by the poster version of this?
Posted in Truly unfortunate representations of data
Tagged careers, math, representations
Here’s a map of the United States. It comes from the Common Core State Standards website.
It’s a fine map. Nice fall colors. Beautiful gradients.
But dig the key. The yellow states? CCSS have been adopted there. The orange states? Not yet adopted.
Not yet?
Nice spin. But not all that honest, really.
This Truly Unfortunate Representation of Data (TURD) is so wrong in so, so many ways. Perhaps the least of these is the mathematics.
If the large figure represents 300,000 and the small one represents 827, then (by area), the large should be about 19 times the height of the small. I added the bars to the right to demonstrate that kneeling, the large is more than 21 times the height of the small. But she’s on her knees, so must be much taller in actuality.
And if it’s by height, the large figure should be 300 times as tall.
And this objection on quantitative grounds ignores the salacious poses and stiletto heels.
So, so wrong.
It’s actually a really interesting piece of journalism, pushing back on claims that would be easy to mindlessly accept. I applaud that. But the graphic has got to go.
Source: City Pages/Village Voice (graphic only in print version).